Give tiles a minimum area rather than a minimum width and height (#2513)

This seems to result in more sensible cropping and allocation of space across the board, in my testing.
This commit is contained in:
Robin 2024-07-26 06:50:44 -04:00 committed by GitHub
parent d062871f41
commit 3b38a5322c
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG Key ID: B5690EEEBB952194
2 changed files with 16 additions and 21 deletions

View File

@ -93,7 +93,6 @@ export interface GridArrangement {
columns: number; columns: number;
} }
const tileMinHeight = 130;
const tileMaxAspectRatio = 17 / 9; const tileMaxAspectRatio = 17 / 9;
const tileMinAspectRatio = 4 / 3; const tileMinAspectRatio = 4 / 3;
const tileMobileMinAspectRatio = 2 / 3; const tileMobileMinAspectRatio = 2 / 3;
@ -110,11 +109,14 @@ export function arrangeTiles(
// use of screen space for n tiles without making those tiles too small or // use of screen space for n tiles without making those tiles too small or
// too cropped (having an extreme aspect ratio) // too cropped (having an extreme aspect ratio)
const gap = width < 800 ? 16 : 20; const gap = width < 800 ? 16 : 20;
const tileMinWidth = width < 500 ? 150 : 180; const area = width * minHeight;
// Magic numbers that make tiles scale up nicely as the window gets larger
const tileArea = Math.pow(Math.sqrt(area) / 8 + 125, 2);
const tilesPerPage = Math.min(tileCount, area / tileArea);
let columns = Math.min( const columns = Math.min(
// Don't create more columns than we have items for // Don't create more columns than we have items for
tileCount, tilesPerPage,
// The ideal number of columns is given by a packing of equally-sized // The ideal number of columns is given by a packing of equally-sized
// squares into a grid. // squares into a grid.
// width / column = height / row. // width / column = height / row.
@ -122,26 +124,18 @@ export function arrangeTiles(
// ∴ columns = sqrt(width / height * number of squares). // ∴ columns = sqrt(width / height * number of squares).
// Except we actually want 16:9-ish tiles rather than squares, so we // Except we actually want 16:9-ish tiles rather than squares, so we
// divide the width-to-height ratio by the target aspect ratio. // divide the width-to-height ratio by the target aspect ratio.
Math.ceil(Math.sqrt((width / minHeight / tileMaxAspectRatio) * tileCount)), Math.round(
Math.sqrt((width / minHeight / tileMinAspectRatio) * tilesPerPage),
),
); );
let rows = Math.ceil(tileCount / columns); let rows = tilesPerPage / columns;
// If all the tiles could fit on one page, we want to ensure that they do by
// not leaving fractional rows hanging off the bottom
if (tilesPerPage === tileCount) rows = Math.ceil(rows);
let tileWidth = (width - (columns + 1) * gap) / columns; let tileWidth = (width - (columns + 1) * gap) / columns;
let tileHeight = (minHeight - (rows - 1) * gap) / rows; let tileHeight = (minHeight - (rows - 1) * gap) / rows;
// Impose a minimum width and height on the tiles
if (tileWidth < tileMinWidth) {
// In this case we want the tile width to determine the number of columns,
// not the other way around. If we take the above equation for the tile
// width (w = (W - (c - 1) * g) / c) and solve for c, we get
// c = (W + g) / (w + g).
columns = Math.floor((width + gap) / (tileMinWidth + gap));
rows = Math.ceil(tileCount / columns);
tileWidth = (width - (columns + 1) * gap) / columns;
tileHeight = (minHeight - (rows - 1) * gap) / rows;
}
if (tileHeight < tileMinHeight) tileHeight = tileMinHeight;
// Impose a minimum and maximum aspect ratio on the tiles // Impose a minimum and maximum aspect ratio on the tiles
const tileAspectRatio = tileWidth / tileHeight; const tileAspectRatio = tileWidth / tileHeight;
// We enforce a different min aspect ratio in 1:1s on mobile // We enforce a different min aspect ratio in 1:1s on mobile
@ -153,7 +147,6 @@ export function arrangeTiles(
tileWidth = tileHeight * tileMaxAspectRatio; tileWidth = tileHeight * tileMaxAspectRatio;
else if (tileAspectRatio < minAspectRatio) else if (tileAspectRatio < minAspectRatio)
tileHeight = tileWidth / minAspectRatio; tileHeight = tileWidth / minAspectRatio;
// TODO: We might now be hitting the minimum height or width limit again
return { tileWidth, tileHeight, gap, columns }; return { tileWidth, tileHeight, gap, columns };
} }

View File

@ -75,7 +75,9 @@ export const makeSpotlightPortraitLayout: CallLayout<
const { width } = useObservableEagerState(minBounds); const { width } = useObservableEagerState(minBounds);
const { gap, tileWidth, tileHeight } = arrangeTiles( const { gap, tileWidth, tileHeight } = arrangeTiles(
width, width,
0, // TODO: We pretend that the minimum height is the width, because the
// actual minimum height is difficult to calculate
width,
model.grid.length, model.grid.length,
); );
const tileModels: GridTileModel[] = useMemo( const tileModels: GridTileModel[] = useMemo(